"When the artist is alive in any person, he becomes an inventive, searching, daring, self-impressive creature. Where others close the book he opens it and shows that there are still more pages to see..." Robert Henry
The past year has been one of connection for The Paul Gruchow Foundation with the inclusion on our website of new, previously unpublished Paul Gruchow Journal writing. In addition to making that archival writing available to a wider audience, we have been supporting important projects undertaken by scholars, researchers, creative writers, a photographer and a land artist – all relevant to our mission: “Helping people explore connections between community, creativity, nature and mental health.”
Dr. Christian Knoeller, a professor at Purdue University, continues his work on an original, wide ranging book of “eco-criticism” about Midwestern Environmental Writers, with a chapter exploring the nature essays of Paul Gruchow.
John Duren, a Minnesota based photographer, is currently Lead Photographer at the Jay C. Hormel
Nature Center in Austin, where he recently completed a photo essay, THE ESSENCE OF PLACE.
John has proposed developing a photo essay around Paul Gruchow's second book, THE NECESSITY OF EMPTY PLACES. We're excited about this possibility. John's stunning nature photograpy can be seen on this website.
Joshua Preston, who grew up in Paul Gruchow's hometown of Montevideo, Minnesota has proposed
writing an essay about Paul's GRASS ROOTS: The Universe Of Home. Joshua is a bio-ethics
researcher at Baylor University in Houston, Texas, has an on line blog, and is a poet. His poem,
“Walking With Paul Gruchow”, will be published on this website.
Doug Carlson, a former colleague of Paul's at Concordia College in Moorhead, Minnesota and an
Assistant Editor of The Georgia Review, has written an essay exploring Paul's approach to writing
his memoir, LETTERS TO A YOUNG MADMAN. We will post publication information aboutDoug's essay
as soon as it is available.
Moira Bateman, a Minneapolis Land Artist, has incorporated some of Paul's essays from WORLDS
WITHIN A WORLD: Visits To Minnesota's Scientific and Natural Areas into her “Elements In Material” exhibit at the University of Minnesota Architecture and Landscape Architecture Library.
She has also posted some of Paul's previously unpublished journal entries, poems and photographs in her installation space. Her remarkable work, which captures the wildness within and all around us, can be viewed at the library from January 23 until February 23, 2015. Links to Moira's website, as well as the exhibit, can be found here, along with an interview and photographs of her work. As part of the exhibit, I will be discussing and reading Paul's nature essays on February 18, from 1:30 –3:00 pm.
Here is a link to my readings and discussion mentioned above:
Please remember, we are a 501.c3 non profit organization. Your donations are tax deductible
and will help us fulfill our mission, sponsor artist in residence projects, continue to archive
Paul Gruchow's writing, develop an annual retreat, and maintain this website.
All the best,
Director: The Paul Gruchow Foundation
Please scroll down for an interview with Moira Bateman and a link to her website.
INTERVIEW WITH MOIRA BATEMAN
How did you come to be interested in landscape architecture, and how did that interest lead you to make "land art"?
I had wanted to be an artist my whole life since I was probably 5 years old. I also loved being outdoors and the natural world. I didn't know a lot about Landscape Architecture before I started graduate school, but it seemed like a field that combined these two interests. I first became aware of land art because of an amazing professor I had at the University of Minnesota, Julie Bargmann, now of D.I.R.T. Studio and the University of Virginia School Architecture. She is an innovator in regenerative landscapes. Julie introduced me to land art. I was really excited about especially Robert Smithson's work. Everyone loved "Spiral Jetty”.
My first piece of land art was a barbed wire and soil chair. It was a graduate school studio project regarding the re-use/reclamation of land contaminated by industry and a nearby superfund site. The land happened to be across the alley from my grandma's house, so I used soil from her vegetable garden for the chair.
How is land art different than sculpture which employs textile as a medium,e.g. the work of Nick Cage, which is sometimes referred to as "performance art"?
What were you trying to achieve in your current installation at theUniversity of Minnesota?
Did any nature writers influence that work? If so, how?
Because my current work is related to ideas about land and is made with the land itself, it may be considered land art.
For my current installation I wanted to make a series of mixed media fiber based sculptures that interpret a cross section of natural landscapes. I hoped they would be something like a poem about that place.
The writer who has influenced my work most is Patricia Eakins. She is not a “nature writer” but writes about the natural world in a surreal, metaphoric and mythical way. Patricia's work “The Hungry Girls” and the play it was made into inspired my first textile art series “Momenta Animale” and my work thinking about humanity and our inherent wildness and connection to wild nature.
How is your work like “a poem”?
What are the base materials of your sculptures?
Like a poem in that a poem is “a piece of writing that partakes of the nature of both speech and song that is nearly always rhythmical, usually metaphorical, and often exhibits such formal elements as meter, rhyme, and stanzaic structure."
I see the sculptures as being somewhat like this. rhythmic, metaphorical. The formal elements I’m putting together are silk, wool, beeswax and pigment and also the text of the species lists in a unique and structural way to be experienced visually and to evoke a feeling. I see sculptures and poems as highly edited objects, crafted down to an essence of something the maker wants to communicate.
My base materials are silk and wool. Both are organic and come from animals. I have used both sheep’s wool and bison wool. I have added vegetable and mineral matter to my work by bundle-printing or staining the silk with plant parts and the chemistry of natural waterways on sites where I’ve worked. The silk I’ve used is a tussah silk. It’s a peace silk that is fair traded and the moths are allowed to fly away. This leaves interesting natural variations in the material. This silk is paper like and very thin. It is stronger than it looks. It has a skin like quality somewhat like the skin of an onion. It is somewhat transparent yet dense and stiff enough to have presence. I like rough cut and frayed edges. For stitching I use silk thread. I work with hand stitching parts together in a casual/irregular manner. I use machine free stitching to create dense repetitive areas of texture and line. I add wool to the pieces by needle felting it into the silk. I feel like the wool gives the pieces an added aliveness and wildness. I love the texture of the wool and working with it. I like to distress areas of the silk with the needle felting tools in additional areas where there is no wool. There are a number of ways to do this and it creates various textures in the silk. I’ve also used a beeswax and pigment product which I paint onto the silk. This is applied to a base coat of black textile paint which I drip and press into the fabric. The beeswax and pigment allows me to create layers of subtle tone and color which I base on the foundation colors that are on the silk from the waterway and plant stains. I think these marks end up looking like flowing and pooling water. I have also used a typewriter to type plant and animal species names onto the silk. I enjoy the repetitive and meditative nature of this and many of the processes which I use in my work.
How is your land art connected to the nature essays of Paul Gruchow?
I first learned about Paul Gruchow’s work only in 2014 when I was beginning work on my project “Elements in Material: Lost Lake Peatland to Pin Oak Prairie”. A DNR person mentioned Paul's book “Worlds within a World" to me. I was really interested that both Paul and I had come up with the idea to create a body of work based on reflections on a number of Scientific and Natural Areas to represent a cross section of landscape types across the state of Minnesota. I was working with 10 of the 149 SNAs, and Paul had chosen two of the same for “Worlds within a World” -- Lost Lake Peatland and Gneiss Outcrops. I felt a connection with him and wanted to learn more about his life’s work and include some of that into my exhibition a the University. I am thoroughly enjoying the process of getting to know Paul through The Paul Gruchow Foundation and his work. It will be interesting to see how it may influence my work in the future.
I have one more question.
I see Paul Gruchow's writing as a gift, in the sense Lewis Hyde means that art is a gift -- that expression of beauty which the dead pass onto the living through the medium of the artist. Do you have a similar view of your work as a land artist?
Yes. I think the Lewis Hyde idea is very evocative. I like it.
Moira Bateman's Exhibition of Land Art “ELEMENTS IN MATERIAL: Lost Lake Peatland to Pin Oak Prairie” will be presented at the University of Minnesota Architecture and Landscape Architecture Library, 89 Church St. S.E., Minneapolis from January 23 to February 23, 2015.
Very few books change the world. Not very many even try. Paul Gruchow’s Letters to a Young Madman has that potential and that ambition in taking on the issue of how the mentally ill are treated by mental health professionals and the culture at large. Based on a manuscript that Gruchow left behind when he died in 2004, the book encountered years of obstacles and delays before finally being published in 2012 by Levins Publishing thanks to the relentless efforts of Gruchow’s literary executor and friend Louis Martinelli. Letters is a book that deserves a wider audience for its eloquent and profound thesis: that the mentally ill should be seen as fully human. (If you believe that they already are, you need to read the book.)
The wider audience that the book deserves would include anyone suffering major depression or other debilitating mental illness, as well as people who work in the field of mental health. The 2012 national year-end booklists, however, made no mention of the book, perhaps because Levins Publishing is a small, low profile regional press. The book was nominated for a Minnesota Book Award but has not received much attention outside Gruchow’s home state. Another factor besides coming from a small publisher is undoubtedly the perception that Letters must be a depressing book. Readers are, quite understandably, reluctant to pick up a book seen as being about depression, suicide, and loss of hope.
That perception is incorrect. In spite of the dark moments and insights the book describes and in spite of Gruchow’s death by prescription drug overdose, Letters is ultimately a work of hope—hope that something good might come out of describing the crushing reality of major depression, that it might help others deal with the life-altering reality of mental illness. Gruchow describes the darkness that comes from depression, but he repeatedly finds some light in that darkness. Late in the book, after recounting years of living with thoughts of suicide and various treatments for his depression including Electroconvulsive Therapy, prescription medications, psychotherapy, and Dialectical Behavior Therapy, he takes a restoring walk through pine trees near Duluth. Suddenly we hear the voice of the younger Gruchow among his “friends”: “White and purple astors bloomed, jewelweeds sparkled, goldenrods turned every sunny nook brilliant yellow. The blue fruits of the bluebeard lilies vied with the scarlet hips of the wild roses for attention” (204). His depression briefly relents, and he tells us that “the feeling of vitality lingered for two days” (204). Even when it fades, he holds on to hope: “The darkness, as it does, closed in again, but I had the conviction this time that, if I could just get there, I knew where to go to find the light” (204). He never gives up on the belief that some path to recovery is possible.
There is, of course, no happy ending. Gruchow himself makes a point of establishing from the start that this will be truthful book about a difficult and serious subject and therefore will not be “a good read” or “amusing” (1). He makes it clear that this won’t be like a visit to Lake Wobegon. Many passages in the book are emotionally wrenching—from his accounts of losing all sense of autonomy when he is hospitalized, to his contemplation of suicide, to his vivid account of lying on a gurney, awaiting Electroconvulsive Therapy. Other passages simply paint a picture of what it’s like to suffer major depression: “I once sat at my desk for three straight days, intent upon stamping an envelope” (19). There is also no one simple message. He faults others for dismissing and ignoring the mentally ill—for building psychiatric wards that do not consider their needs at all, for pushing treatments that may have devastating side effects— but he also finds fault with himself: “My biggest mistake was in allowing myself to be called disabled. When I did so, I became, in my own mind, disabled. And once that happened, I was disabled” (55).
What good might come from describing the reality of serious mental illness? The book provides an answer: we could learn that the mentally ill are still people; that they may be capable of thinking about their own condition; and that any real cure has to involve an internal process, not just an external medical intervention. We could learn that clinical depression and other serious mental illnesses take us into deep water, places where most of us do not like to swim. But if you are in the ocean, you might welcome some advice and some companionship. Letters to a Young Madman, against all expectations, might be your lifeline, and just might change the world.
LETTER TO THE WORLD: PAUL GRUCHOW'S LETTERS TO A YOUNG MADMAN
by: Louis Martinelli
We say that one gets cancer, or a cold, or kidney disease. One would
never think to say that one is cancer. But we say that one is depressed,
or bipolar, or schizophrenic. A disease of the body is a condition. But
a disease of the mind, we think, is a state of being. We no longer
believe, as we did 250 years ago, that the mentally ill are animals,
but we are not yet ready to grant that they are fully human either.
In a voice remarkably clear, eloquent and calm, Paul Gruchow – author of
LETTERS TO A YOUNG MADMAN – explores a double injury inflicted on the mentally ill: The
illness itself, with its often debilitating symptoms, and the more insidious injury made by society,
stigmatization. There is little evidence that the medicalization of what was once called “madness” –
a term Gruchow uses repeatedly in this eliptical memoir – has destigmatized the nearly 300
afflictions now classified as mental disorders in the latest version of the Diagnostic And Statistical
Manual – the bible of the mental health treatment profession.
While Gruchow does not consider this expanding diagnostic umbrella to be an argument
against treatment, his account of his own experience with certain aspects of the treatment system
at the turn of the 21st century – he committed suicide at age 56, in 2004 – is sobering. In several
detailed, Kafquesque depictions of life in a mental hospital, infantilization of patients is the
norm in everything from baby shampoo to toys. The one notable exception to this pattern
of learned helplessness are daily routines so boring, in the age of Piaget and Montessori, we would no
longer subject an infant to them. Television, children's games, crafts, coloring books, and just sitting
alone or with other patients, hour after hour, seems to reinforce the popular stereotype of those
suffering from mental illness as incapable of higher levels of thinking, creativity, self-initiative, or
feeling. The hospital environment proved to be, predictably, non-therapeutic for Gruchow, boredom
increasing depression: His genius level IQ, tested a few years before his death, was 187.
Gruchow cites David L. Rosenhan's classic study, BEING SANE IN INSANE PLACES, which
followed a group of professional researchers after their admittance to a mental hospital, concluding
that no one on the hospital staff could tell the difference between the presumably sane professionals
and the patients diagnosed with mental illness. This role reversal might be comical – as is the movie
WHAT ABOUT BOB in which a patient suffering from multiple phobias disrupts the life and work
of a narcissistic psycho-therapist – were it not for the unsettling questions it raises about the reliability
of psychiatric diagnosis and about the nature of mental illness itself. If diagnosis and treatment are as
much art as science, the difference between the sane and insane members of any group might best be
understood as a continuum rather than a fixed point. If that is the case, LETTERS TO A YOUNG
MADMAN could be read as one person's journey through a continuum of good and bad days, of
happiness and sadness, of remembering and forgetting, of grieving and being unable to grieve, of
moments in which illness defines the journey and of moments in which telling the story becomes a way
to defy illness, leaving behind a map for others to follow.
LETTERS could not be more timely. The World Health Organization has named depression
the leading health crisis in the world, its impact becoming deeper and more widespread.
Wondering, as I have, who the “young madman” might be to whom these letters are addressed, a friend
familiar with Gruchow's story suggested they were written by the author to his younger self, when he
was experiencing his illness as a shameful secret, afraid of being found out. In breaking a silence he
calls “the cornerstone of evil” Gruchow becomes a modern Job, giving voice to all those who suffer
from not only mental illness, but whatever affliction tries the soul.
LETTER FROM THE DIRECTOR
Welcome to the Paul Gruchow Foundation Web-site!
Incorporated in Minnesota in February, 2007 as a tax exempt charitable organization, our mission is to help increase appreciation for Minnesota author Paul Gruchow’s writing and to foster awareness of the relationship between nature, creativity, community and mental health -- themes that are important in Paul’s life and work. Our goals are to encourage dialogue about creating sustainable natural and human communities, to be advocates for mentally ill and other marginalized persons, and to explore the role creativity and imagination play in mental health. A Paul Gruchow center, library, newsletter, annual retreat, and community based Artist In Residence program are projects for which we are currently seeking funding and other support. Your contributions and personal involvement are critical to making these dreams a reality.
This web-site will support our mission by making literary work by and about Paul Gruchow available to a wider readership, by providing information about Paul Gruchow and his legacy, and by providing information about the evolving work of the foundation bearing his name.